What Is It?
Well, I can tell you what it's not. It's not Mike Tyson's Punch Out!!,
the game we said would never make it to the Virtual Console! Instead this is Punch-Out!!, the Mr. Dream edition that was released soon after Iron Mike had his run-ins with the law. The good news is that this is still the great game of boxing you remember, even if it doesn't have a certain pugilist who is a little too into biting his opponents. This version includes all of wacky characters you've grown to love, the insane difficulty and that nice cameo from none other than Mario himself. And that's not all, at $5 this version is a steal ... even if it doesn't come with the one character that everybody wants. Thankfully you will hardly even notice Mike Tyson's absents, so if that was the one thing keeping you from buying this NES sports game then forget about it and get those Nintendo points ready!
Does It Still Hold Up?
While a lot of early sports games end up being too rudimentary for their own good, Punch-Out!! works remarkably well because of the way it was built. The original Punch-Out!! wasn't just about beating up your opponents like Fight Night and other boxing games, instead it required you to actually watch for patterns and strike only when your opponent was vulnerable. This gimmick required that you had a good eye and a lot of skill, something that ultimately gave the game a whole lot of depth. It's still fun to go back and play through these characters and re-learn their patterns, which makes this game easy to recommend even twenty years later.
Is It Worth The Money?
At a mere five dollars it's hard to go wrong with the Punch-Out!! While I would have liked to have seen Nintendo get the license back and do a Mike Tyson's Punch-Out!!, I can certainly understand why they opted to just release this Mr. Dream edition. If you've never played through Punch-Out!! then what are you waiting for, and if you already love the game then chances are you've already spent your $5 to buy it. No matter who you are, Punch-Out!! on the Virtual Console is a great deal.